Wednesday, November 18, 2026Today’s Paper

MPs turn on minister over DG’s absence from forensic report briefing

Members of Parliament challenged Public Works and Infrastructure Minister Dean Macpherson on Wednesday over the absence of the department’s Director-General (DG) from a briefing on a forensic report into the acquisition and related material irregularities.


The disagreement emerged during a meeting of the Portfolio Committee on Public Works and Infrastructure when members debated whether the briefing should proceed in public or behind closed doors.


Committee chairperson Carol Mokgadi Phiri confirmed that seven members had voted in favour of a public, televised meeting, while two supported holding it in camera.


“Honourable members, the meeting must proceed in public, being televised. That is the decision,” Phiri said.


Macpherson indicated that he was willing to circulate the report and present it himself, explaining that departmental officials were uncomfortable doing so because of the threat of possible legal action.


“The problem is that the officials feel very uncomfortable about this because of the threat of legal action. I think I’m going to have to present the report myself,” he said.


Committee members questioned why the DG, as the department’s accounting officer, was not prepared to present the report.


One member said allowing the minister to take over the presentation would set an undesirable precedent for parliamentary oversight.


“I don’t think that we are setting the correct precedents when we let today the officials and accounting officers tell us what to do,” the member said.


The member said the committee should maintain its established practice of receiving reports from accounting officers, with the minister responding to questions.
Another member questioned the department’s concerns about litigation, arguing that any legal action would be directed at the department rather than individual officials.


“It doesn’t make sense to me, honestly speaking, that you are going to take legal steps against the report that we asked you to formulate for us,” the member said.
The discussion also raised concerns about alleged intimidation and threats against individuals involved in investigations.


One committee member told the meeting that some MPs had experienced threats, including threatening phone calls, and questioned whether departmental officials were also facing intimidation.


“Some of us, we are being intimidated. There were attempts of us being assassinated, so to speak,” the member said.


The MP urged officials not to allow intimidation to interfere with their accountability obligations, adding: “My plea is don’t be afraid of death, because one day, all of us, we are going to die.”


The member also questioned whether officials’ reluctance was solely related to litigation or whether there were other issues the committee needed to know about.
“Are you being threatened? Are you being called by other people, faceless people, so to speak?” the member asked.


Macpherson maintained that officials’ concerns were linked to possible legal action and asked members to handle the report with sensitivity.


He said he had initially tried to avoid discussing the matter publicly but was now required to explain the department’s position following the committee’s decision.


“I would ask, in that consideration, that you would consider what I’ve put before you and which I’ve tried to avoid having this discussion in public, but obviously it is now necessary,” he said.


The minister offered to provide the report in electronic format but asked members to consider the confidentiality concerns raised by the department.


Phiri suggested that the document could be distributed through an encrypted parliamentary email system, which would require members to use their identification details to access it.


The chairperson also expressed concern about the possibility of the report being leaked, noting that information relating to the Telkom Towers matter had already appeared in the media.


She questioned the trust between members, saying: “You don’t trust each other amongst yourselves. It has been leaked from the department side.”


The committee further raised concerns about the time available to scrutinise the report, with members arguing that they could not properly deliberate on its contents during the meeting.


Macpherson undertook to consult the department on the technical arrangements for securely distributing the document and said he would provide feedback within the next day or two.


The possibility of reconvening on a Saturday to allow members sufficient time to consider the report was also raised.


The committee indicated that it would continue engaging on the matter, with the dispute over the DG’s role in presenting the report remaining a key issue.

Don't Miss