Sunday, November 22, 2026Today’s Paper

‘I don’t know’: DG exposed over questionable Mazars appointment at NAC

The Old Assembly Chamber in Parliament, Cape Town.
The Old Assembly Chamber in Parliament, Cape Town. File photo. Deon000 / Wikimedia Commons (CC0).

Dr Cynthia Khumalo, the Department of Sport, Arts and Culture’s director-general, has admitted she cannot say whether the National Arts Council (NAC) followed procurement rules when it appointed Mazars to investigate its PESP funding.

“I don’t know the processes that were followed in terms of procurement for the service provider. That is why I was seeking support from NAC management,” Khumalo said on Tuesday, 10 November.

Nehawu has complained that Mazars was not properly appointed.

EFF MP Eugene Mthethwa put the question to her in the Portfolio Committee on Sport, Arts and Culture.

“According to the procurement policies, there’s a process you follow to appoint a service provider. Was that process followed, DG? Do you know whether that process was followed correctly or not? Do you have confidence that the appointment was done correctly, according to the policy, and with transparency?” he asked.

After Khumalo’s answer, Mthethwa said she should have known.

“I thought, DG, you said you got responses from the NAC after requesting an independent investigation. That investigation would have picked up whether it was done correctly, because one of Nehawu’s complaints was that that particular firm was not correctly appointed. So it’s the allegations I want to deal with,” he said.

NAC acting CEO Lebogang Magoera said Mazars was appointed, but he could not explain how.

“There was the process of an independent investigation regarding the CEO and the CFO. The service provider appointed in that regard was CDH. The Mazars matter the honourable member is referring to dealt with matters of PESP and other things. So it was a separate process. But yes, it was appointed,” Magoera said.

He offered to bring in acting CFO Reshma Bhoola to answer. Mthethwa objected.

“Give me the logic of the person who has been implicated responding to questions about her participation in what is alleged to have been an irregular appointment. What would be the logic? One of the complaints around the very same members is that they have been interfering with processes, and the board was covering,” he said.

He said the committee had been lied to before.

“Even on the day they were released, what was the term they used? Special leave. There were lies around that. We were told the tools of trade had been taken away from them, when they were just at home, sitting with the tools of trade,” Mthethwa said.

Magoera said the process happened before his time.

“Now, my limitation, unfortunately, is that there were other colleagues there when the appointment of Mazars took place. I believe there was an interim CEO at the time,” he said.

Mthethwa said Mazars kept getting work.

“Mazars has been appointed so many times on matters,” he said.

In its presentation to the committee, Nehawu said the Mazars investigation into the Presidential Employment Stimulus Programme (PESP) had found administrative, governance and financial management failures.

In August, Nehawu’s Damien Naidu told Africa Daily the union wants the Special Investigating Unit to trace funds from NAC accounts to beneficiaries. The union’s petition says the NAC distributed more than R1.5 billion over five years.

Khumalo confirmed DSAC received a letter from the Public Protector on 6 August 2025 listing issues raised by Nehawu.

Don't Miss