The University of the Western Cape has confirmed that it reached a private settlement with an internal candidate it passed over for the vice-chancellor’s job.
Patriotic Alliance MP Ashley Sauls told Parliament’s Portfolio Committee on Higher Education on Friday13 November that the candidate, a coloured woman professor, was the preferred candidate and scored higher than the man council appointed, Professor Robert Balfour.
“There was a settlement because council decided not to give the job to the preferred candidate, who was a classified coloured female professor, even though she fulfilled all the requirements. Council decided to reject her and give it to the current VC, who scored less. I have nothing personally against him, sir. I have a problem that the institution gives the perception that you were appointed on merit in comparison to a coloured, highly capable female professor. And the truth is you were not. She scored higher than you and she wasn’t given the job,” Sauls said.
Balfour confirmed the settlement. Asked whether he was aware of it, he said: “Yes, I am aware.”
He said he did not know why the university had settled, and that he was not told how candidates were scored.
The deputy chairperson of council also confirmed the settlement but would not give reasons.
“Of course there is a settlement. Can you please allow us, honourable member, to provide you with that detail in writing? Because I don’t want to now make an assumption, because I don’t remember interacting with the discussion around the settlement,” he said.
He said decisions of council’s senior appointments committee were kept confidential.
“What we don’t want to experience is a situation where those decisions are used to question the authority of council to make that final decision, because council does not just rubber-stamp. It must make a consideration and take that decision,” he said.
Registrar Nita Lawton-Misra said the institutional forum had opposed the recommendation.
“The institutional forum actually opposed the SACC recommendation. Senate had to go to a vote, and Senate, I think, supported the recommendation. The institutional forum was actually very vocal about not supporting the recommendation,” she said.
“In the first case that we talked about, it’s not as simple as what was made out to be. We actually went through a second round of interviews as well. So there was a lot that happened in between interviews. And finally, when the decision was taken by council, it took into account everything that took place. I’m not at liberty to speak about those details,” Lawton-Misra said.
Sauls said the Employment Equity Act should have tipped the scales.
“Here you have a coloured female who fulfils the academic requirement. She’s a professor who fulfils the experience requirement. Then, in terms of the equity, the candidate you have appointed is a white South African male, over and above a coloured South African female who, between the two, should have received preference. You failed as a council to do that. You then went to settle privately with the coloured female that had to get the job,” he said.
EFF MP Sihle Lonzi called Sauls’ line of questioning “racial sensationalism”. He withdrew the remark after Sauls raised a point of order, but then accused him of “showboating”.
Balfour’s appointment was contested when it was announced in 2024. Much of the criticism came from supporters of internal candidate Professor Vivienne Lawack, who had the backing of the university’s senate.
