Tuesday, November 17, 2026Today’s Paper

Public participation concerns emerge over Traditional and Khoi-San Leadership Bill

The Parliament of South Africa in Cape Town.
The Parliament of South Africa in Cape Town. File photo. Dietmar Rabich / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Concerns over meaningful public participation, language accessibility and accountability have emerged in written submissions on the Traditional and Khoi-San Leadership Bill, as Parliament considers legislation intended to regulate traditional and Khoi-San leadership structures.

The concerns formed part of discussions during a virtual meeting of the Portfolio Committee on Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (COGTA) on Tuesday.

The Traditional and Khoi-San Leadership Bill was tabled in the National Assembly on 21 April 2026 and referred to the committee for consideration.

Its introduction follows a Constitutional Court judgment in Mogale and Others v Speaker of the National Assembly and Others, which found that Parliament had failed to fulfil its constitutional obligation to facilitate public involvement before passing the Traditional and Khoi-San Leadership Act of 2019.

Among the submissions received was one by Zakariyya Desai, who questioned whether the public participation process was sufficiently accessible and inclusive.

Desai argued that meaningful consultation was central to avoiding a repeat of the shortcomings identified by the Constitutional Court.

“The conduct of meaningful public participation, which is the very defect that sank the 2019 Act,” he wrote.

He raised concerns about the Bill’s length and technical language, the availability of translations, and whether rural communities had adequate opportunities to participate. He also called for public hearings in provincial centres and rural districts, with proceedings conducted in relevant local languages and supported by translation services.

Desai recommended an eight-week community radio campaign, including call-in programmes, to widen public awareness. He further proposed that the committee provide written responses to submissions, explaining which recommendations had been accepted, rejected or partly adopted.

Questions about the recognition and representation of Khoi-San communities also featured in the submissions.

Margaret Mary Visagie, representing the San Tribe of Mpumalanga, called for the recognition of Khoi-San people as the First Indigenous Peoples and for their historical political, social, cultural and territorial systems to be acknowledged.

She argued that recognition processes should take account of oral history, customary evidence, family lineage and community testimony, rather than relying solely on documentary records. Her submission also highlighted the need to protect cultural sites, burial grounds and indigenous languages.

The Land and Accountability Research Centre (LARC) raised concerns about the powers and accountability of traditional leadership structures.

It warned that the Bill could effectively establish a “fourth level of government” by assigning broad governmental responsibilities to traditional structures, potentially creating uncertainty around their relationship with municipalities and other spheres of government.

LARC also questioned whether communities would have sufficient influence over decisions affecting them, particularly those involving land and agreements with external parties.

It cautioned that reporting requirements would offer limited accountability if communities could not access the reports, plans and budgets produced by traditional councils.

Don't Miss