EFF leader Julius Malema has questioned DA Johannesburg mayoral candidate Helen Zille’s decision to oppose his defamation action in the Western Cape High Court, accusing her of attempting to have the dispute heard outside Johannesburg.
Malema posted Zille’s Notice of Opposition on X on Monday, indicating that the matter had been filed in the High Court of South Africa, Western Cape Division, in Cape Town. The documents identify Malema as the first applicant, the EFF as the second applicant and Zille as the respondent.
He argued that Johannesburg High Court was the appropriate venue for the legal battle, given that the comments at the centre of the dispute were made in the city.
“We are suing her in Johannesburg, but she insists that the case be heard in Cape Town. What does she know about that court that gives her such confidence?” Malema wrote.
Western Cape High Court is located in the Western Cape Province, where DA has been in power for 17 years.
He said Zille made the disputed claims in the city where she is campaigning to become mayor.
“She made these nonsensical remarks here in Johannesburg about Johannesburg, and she is a mayoral candidate here. Yet she wants to run to the Cape Town High Court. One day, the truth will come out. We will fight this case where the alleged conduct took place,” he added.
The legal confrontation began after Zille appeared in an eNCA interview on Sunday, November 8, in which she accused former Johannesburg mayor Herman Mashaba of effectively serving as an EFF mayor during his 2016 to 2019 administration.
She alleged that Mashaba depended on Malema’s influence to maintain his position and allowed the EFF leader to interfere in important municipal affairs.
Among her claims were that Malema had influenced the running of City Power, interfered in a municipal fleet tender to benefit companies allegedly linked to him and played a role in the appointment of Shadrack Sibiya as head of the city’s anti-corruption unit.
Following the interview, Malema’s legal representatives, England Slabbert Attorneys, sent Zille a letter of demand on November 9, accusing her of making damaging allegations without a factual basis.
The attorneys called on Zille to withdraw her statements, apologise publicly and commit in writing to refraining from repeating the claims. She was given until the close of business on November 11 to comply.
Zille, however, rejected the demands through her attorneys, Cape Town-based law firm Minde Schapiro & Smith Inc.
Responding to the letter, the firm made its position clear, stating: “We have received your letter dated 9th November 2026. The answer to all your client’s demands is: No. See you in court.”
Malema has since indicated his intention to pursue a R1 million defamation claim against Zille in Joburg High Court and not in the Western Cape High Court.
However, his latest concerns relate to the location of the proceedings, with him insisting that Johannesburg is the appropriate jurisdiction because the statements were allegedly made in the city and related to its municipal affairs.
